National Academy of Sciences | 150 Year Anniversary

Questions? Call 800-624-6242

| Items in cart [0]

The National Academies Press

Rights & Permissions

topleft topright

Proceedings of the International Conference on Scientific Information -- Two Volumes (1959)

Citation Manager

. "Proposed Scope of Area 3." Proceedings of the International Conference on Scientific Information -- Two Volumes. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press, 1959.

Please select a format:

BibTeX EndNote RefMan


Page
541
bottomleft bottomright

The following HTML text is provided to enhance online readability. Many aspects of typography translate only awkwardly to HTML. Please use the page image as the authoritative form to ensure accuracy.


PROPOSED SCOPE OF AREA 3

IN THIS AREA, perhaps more than in any other, one finds a great disparity in the scientific information services and facilities that are available in various disciplines. Many of these differences result from basically different characteristics and problems of the various sciences. Others, however, seem to stem from a lack of organization, experience, or perhaps awareness of the feasibility of adequate bibliographic control.1

In some areas of science, reviews are in their infancy. In medicine, however, the volume and importance of reviews have been sufficient to stimulate the preparation of a Bibliography of Medical Reviews. Some reviews are little more than indexed or annotated bibliographies, whereas others provide more detailed treatment of narrow fields, and a few, such as Nutrition Reviews, attempt a highly critical appraisal of recent work, both individually and collectively, with a view to influencing the direction of future research.

In the matter of compendia there is also a marked difference between fields. A brief search of the chemistry collection at the National Bureau of Standards Library revealed approximately 50 compendia. Yet a search of compendia, similarly defined, in physics yielded barely a dozen titles.

Increased research activity has meant not only increased publication but also more activity in establishing specialized centers for the collection, correlation, and dissemination of scientific information. The classic compendia are now out of date and it is doubtful indeed whether their revision, even on a much augmented scale, will meet future or even current needs. The Landolt Börnstein tables are now being revised in approximately the same format, but the Gmelin Institute is undergoing a significant reorganization—away from compendia and toward reference service. Compendia and reviews have played an important part in the conduct of scientific work and will undoubtedly continue to do so. In many specialized areas, nevertheless, more expeditious collection and more prompt and direct dissemination are required. Here specialized centers or organizations have been established. Some examples of such United States centers are:

The Chemical-Biological Coordination Center

1  

The proposed scope of the Conference Area, as shown here, was prepared during the Spring and Summer of 1956 and provided to all potential contributors as a guide to the aims of the Conference.

 

Page
541
Front Matter (R1-R24)
Opening Session Address (1-8)
Area 1: Literature and Reference Needs of Scientists: Knowledge now available and methods of ascertaining requirements (9-12)
Proposed Scope of Area 1 (13-18)
Study on the Use of Scientific Literature and Reference Services by Scandinavian Scientists and Engineers Engaged in Research Development (19-76)
The Transmission of Scientific Information (77-96)
An Operations Research Study of the Dissemination of Scientific Information (97-130)
Information and Literature Use in a Research and Development Organization (131-162)
Methods by which Research Workers Find Information (163-180)
Determining Requirements for Atomic Energy Information from Reference Questions (181-188)
Systematically Ascertaining Requirements of Scientists for Information (189-194)
How Scientists Actually Learn of Work Important to Them (195-198)
Planned and Unplanned Scientific Information (199-244)
The Use of Technical Literature by Industrial Technologists (245-266)
Requirements of Forest Scientists for Literature and Reference Services (267-276)
The Information-Gathering Habits of American Medical Scientists (277-286)
Use of Scientific Periodicals (287-300)
Summary of Discussion (301-312)
Area 2: The Function and Effectiveness of Abstracting and Indexing Services (313-316)
Proposed Scope of Area 2 (317-320)
An Evaluation of Abstracting Journals and Indexes (321-350)
Analytical Study of a Method for Literature Search in Abstracting Journals (351-376)
The Relation Between Completeness and Effectiveness of a Subject Catalogue (377-380)
Cost Analysis of Bibliographies or Bibliographic Services (381-392)
The Efficiency of Metallurgical Services (393-406)
Subject Slanting in Scientific Abstracting Publications (407-428)
The Importance of Peripheral Publications in the Documentation of Biology (429-434)
Current Medical Literature: A Quantitative Survey of Articles and Journals (435-448)
A Combined Indexing-Abstracting System (449-460)
A Unified Index to Science (461-474)
Lost Information: Unpublished Conference Papers (475-480)
International Cooperation in Physics Abstracting (481-490)
International Cooperative Abstracting on Building: An Appraisal (491-496)
Cooperation and Coordination in Abstracting and Documentation (497-510)
On the Functioning of the All-Union Institute for Scientific and Technical Information of the USSR Academy of Sciences (511-522)
Summary of Discussion (523-536)
Area 3: Effectiveness of Monographs, Compendia, and Specialized Centers: Present trends and new and proposed techniques and types of services (537-540)
Proposed Scope of Area 3 (541-544)
Review Literature and the Chemist (545-570)
The Place of Analytical and Critical Reviews in Any Growing Biological Science and the Service They May Render to Research (571-588)
Recent Trends in Scientific Documentation in South Asia: Problems of Speed and Coverage (589-604)
Scientific Documentation in France (605-612)
Scientific, Technical, and Economic Information in a Research Organization (613-648)
Summary of Discussion (649-660)
Area 4: Organization of Information for Storage and Search: Comparative characteristics of existing systems (661-664)
Proposed Scope of Area 4 (665-670)
Conventional and Inverted Grouping of Codes for Chemical Data (671-686)
The Evaluation of Systems Used in Retrieval Systems on Large Electronic Computers (687-698)
Experience in Developing Information Retrieval Systems (699-710)
Printing Chemical Structures Electronically: Encoded Compounds Searched Generically with IBM-702 (711-730)
Evolution of Document Control in a Materials Deterioration Information Center (731-762)
Retrieval Questions from the Use of Linde's Indexing and Retrieval System (763-770)
Classification with Peek-a-boo for Indexing Documents on Aerodynamics: An Experiment in Retrieval (771-802)
Summary of Discussion (803-812)
Area 5: Organization of Information for Storage and Retrospective Search: Intellectual problems and equipment considerations in the design of new systems (813-816)
Proposed Scope of Area 5 (817-822)
The Basic Types of Information Tasks and Some Methods of Their Solution (823-854)
Subject Analysis for Information Retrieval (855-866)
The Construction of a Faceted Classification for a Special Subject (867-888)
On the Coding of Geometrical Shapes and Other Representations, with Reference to Archaeological Documents (889-902)
Subject-Word Letter Frequencies with Applications to Superimposed Coding (903-916)
The Analogy between Mechanical Translation and Library Retrieval (917-936)
Linguistic Transformations for Information Retrieval (937-950)
Linguistic and Machine Methods for Compiling and Updating the Harvard Automatic Dictionary (951-974)
The Feasability of Machine Searching of English Texts (975-996)
Semantic Matrices (997-1026)
Interlingual Communication in the Sciences (1027-1046)
An Overall Concept of Scientific Documentation Systems and Their Design (1047-1070)
The Possibilities of Far-Reaching Mechanization of Novelty Search of the Patent Literature (1071-1096)
Descriptive Documentation (1097-1116)
Variable Scope Search System: VS8 (1117-1142)
The Haystaq System: Past, Present, and Future (1143-1180)
A Proposed Information Handling System for a Large Research Organization (1181-1202)
Information Handling in a Large Information System (1203-1220)
Tabledex: A New Coordinate Indexing Method for Bound Book Form Bibliographies (1221-1244)
The Comac: An Efficient Punched Card Collating System for the Storage and Retrieval of Information (1245-1254)
Summary of Discussion (1255-1268)
Area 6: Organization of Information for Storage and Retrospective Search: Possibility for a general theory (1269-1272)
Proposed Scope of Area 6 (1273-1274)
The Structure of Information Retrieval Systems (1275-1290)
The Descriptive Continuum: A (1291-1312)
Algebraic Representation of Storage and Retrieval Languages (1313-1326)
A Mathematical Theory of Language Symbols in Retrieval (1327-1364)
Abstract Theory of Retrieval Coding (1365-1382)
Maze Structure and Information Retrieval (1383-1394)
Summary of Discussion (1395-1410)
Area 7: Responsibilities of Government, Professional Societies, Universities (1411-1414)
Proposed Scope of Area 7 (1415-1416)
Responsibilities for Scientific Information in Biology: Proposal for Financing a Comprehensive System (1417-1428)
Responsibility for the Development of Scientific Information as a National Resource (1429-1434)
Differences in International Arrangements for Financial Support of Information Services (1435-1440)
Training for Activity in Scientific Documentation Work (1441-1488)
Training the Scientific Information Officer (1489-1494)
Training for Scientific Information Work in Great Britain (1495-1502)
The ICSU Abstracting Board: The Story of a Venture in International Cooperation (1503-1516)
Creation of an International Center of Scientific Information (1517-1522)
An International Institute for Scientific Information (1523-1534)
Summary of Discussion (1535-1548)
Closing Session (1549-1562)
Financial Support (1563-1564)
Exhibitors (1565-1566)
Roster of Registrants (1567-1606)
Index (1607-1638)

Below are the first 10 and last 10 pages of uncorrected machine-read text (when available) of this chapter, followed by the top 30 algorithmically extracted key phrases from the chapter as a whole.
Intended to provide our own search engines and external engines with highly rich, chapter-representative searchable text on the opening pages of each chapter. Because it is UNCORRECTED material, please consider the following text as a useful but insufficient proxy for the authoritative book pages.

Do not use for reproduction, copying, pasting, or reading; exclusively for search engines.

OCR for page 541
--> PROPOSED SCOPE OF AREA 3 IN THIS AREA, perhaps more than in any other, one finds a great disparity in the scientific information services and facilities that are available in various disciplines. Many of these differences result from basically different characteristics and problems of the various sciences. Others, however, seem to stem from a lack of organization, experience, or perhaps awareness of the feasibility of adequate bibliographic control.1 In some areas of science, reviews are in their infancy. In medicine, however, the volume and importance of reviews have been sufficient to stimulate the preparation of a Bibliography of Medical Reviews. Some reviews are little more than indexed or annotated bibliographies, whereas others provide more detailed treatment of narrow fields, and a few, such as Nutrition Reviews, attempt a highly critical appraisal of recent work, both individually and collectively, with a view to influencing the direction of future research. In the matter of compendia there is also a marked difference between fields. A brief search of the chemistry collection at the National Bureau of Standards Library revealed approximately 50 compendia. Yet a search of compendia, similarly defined, in physics yielded barely a dozen titles. Increased research activity has meant not only increased publication but also more activity in establishing specialized centers for the collection, correlation, and dissemination of scientific information. The classic compendia are now out of date and it is doubtful indeed whether their revision, even on a much augmented scale, will meet future or even current needs. The Landolt Börnstein tables are now being revised in approximately the same format, but the Gmelin Institute is undergoing a significant reorganization—away from compendia and toward reference service. Compendia and reviews have played an important part in the conduct of scientific work and will undoubtedly continue to do so. In many specialized areas, nevertheless, more expeditious collection and more prompt and direct dissemination are required. Here specialized centers or organizations have been established. Some examples of such United States centers are: The Chemical-Biological Coordination Center 1   The proposed scope of the Conference Area, as shown here, was prepared during the Spring and Summer of 1956 and provided to all potential contributors as a guide to the aims of the Conference.  

OCR for page 542
--> Snow-Ice and Permafrost Research Establishment Bio-Sciences Information Exchange American Petroleum Institute Project 44 Manufacturing Chemists Association Project Committee on Spectral Absorption Data Nuclear Data Project Solid Propellants Information Agency Liquid Propellants Information Agency Bibliography Section T.I.D., Library of Congress Thermophysical Properties Research Center, Purdue University Human Relations Area File Historical Records Project, George Washington University Linguistic Center, Indiana University Collection of Survey Materials, Columbia University A number of European centers are interesting in this connection. Some examples are: Gmelin Institute Centre de Documentation, CNRS, Paris Centre de Documentation, IRSID, Saint-Germain Dokumentation der Molekul-Spektroskopie, Weinheim All-Union Institute of Scientific and Technical Information, Academy of Sciences, USSR It is to be expected that such centers will be the first to apply the latest techniques in rapid collection, search, coordination, and dissemination. It is also probable that these centers will expand their services as these new techniques become available. While much of the change may be in the direction of increased and streamlined reference services, a significant increase is to be expected in published abstract bulletins, bibliographies, and technical compendia. It will be important, therefore, to discuss fully the organizational, economic, and technical characteristics of these specialized information centers with particular reference to the impact of machine technology on the organization and services of such centers. This working area should be directed to the following problems: Summary of studies already made of book publication patterns, existing compendia in the major branches of science, and features of existing specialized documentation centers. Evaluation of the effectiveness of a number of typical specialized services. Assessment of these services in terms of new and proposed techniques (such as mechanized searching systems) and types of services that might be established.

OCR for page 543
--> Suggested Conference Papers Characteristics and effectiveness of the monographic literature: A review of the role of scholarly monographs in the utilization of scientific information. The paper should include a discussion based on studies of the way scientists in various fields depend on the monographic literature as contrasted with periodicals. Scientific reviews in the natural sciences: A study and analysis of the development, trends, objectives, and effectiveness of the review literature in the various natural sciences. Reviews in the medical sciences: See item 2 above. The Bibliography of Medical Reviews should provide a good starting point for the analysis. Survey and analysis of existing compendia in the physical sciences: The Index of Mathematical Tables by Fletcher, Miller, and Rosenhead and the quarterly Mathematical Tables and Other Aids to Computation which supplements it provide an excellent example of what can be done to keep track of an ever-growing collection of data. The need in the physical sciences has been recognized for some time. Survey and analysis of existing compendia in the medical and biological sciences. Papers outlining in considerable detail the objectives, organization, staff, facilities, operation, financing, services, effectiveness, and future plans of various information centers. A directory and an analytical summary of services provided by specialized information centers in the United States. A directory and analytical summary of services provided by specialized information centers abroad.

OCR for page 544
--> This page intentionally left blank.

Representative terms from entire chapter:

existing compendia