Click for next page ( 47


The National Academies | 500 Fifth St. N.W. | Washington, D.C. 20001
Copyright © National Academy of Sciences. All rights reserved.
Terms of Use and Privacy Statement



Below are the first 10 and last 10 pages of uncorrected machine-read text (when available) of this chapter, followed by the top 30 algorithmically extracted key phrases from the chapter as a whole.
Intended to provide our own search engines and external engines with highly rich, chapter-representative searchable text on the opening pages of each chapter. Because it is UNCORRECTED material, please consider the following text as a useful but insufficient proxy for the authoritative book pages.

Do not use for reproduction, copying, pasting, or reading; exclusively for search engines.

OCR for page 46
BIRT.To~ Alaskan, L. K. 1986. Medical Jan Ls' ~zzlir~ policies threaten quality. &ienoe~it`~; 34(3):1-4. Alaskan, L. K. and L. Mother. 1983. Fraud in science. British M~i~1 Journal 286:2003-2006. AAhS (American Association for the ~t of Sciences. 1988. Project on Scientific Fray arm Miscorx~uct. Part of a worl~hop Sponsors by the National Conference of Inters and Scientists. Washington, D. C.: author Ar~ell, M. 1983. Editors arm fraud. Ail of Biology Editors Views 6 (2~: 3-8 . Angell, M. 1986. Publish or perish: A proposal. Annals of Internal Medicine 104~2):261-262. Angell, M. and A. S. Relman. 1988. Fraud in bicmedir~H research. New England Journal of Medicine 318~22~:1462-1463. Appelkaum, P. S., L. H. Roth, C. W. Iidz, et al. 1987. False hopes and best data: Consent to research and the Therapeutic misconception. Hastings Center Report. April. Aronson, L. R. 1975. The case of The Came of the Midwife Toad. Behavior Genetics 5~2): 115-125. AAMC (Association of American Medical Colleges). 1982. AA MC Ad Hoc Committee on the Maintenance of High Ethical Standards in the Conduct of Res arch. Journal of Medical Education 57:895-902. AAMC (Association of American M~di~1 Colleges). 1982. m e Maintenance of High Ethical Standards in the Conduct of Research. Washington D.C.: author. AAU (Association of American Universities). 1983. Report of the AAU Committee on the Integrity of Research. Washington D. C.: author. : AAU (Association of American Universities). 1988. Framework for Institutional Policies and Proc cures to Deal with Fraud in Research. Washington, D.C.: author. November. AAU (Association of American Universities). 1988. Framework for Institutional Policies and Procedures to Deal with Fraud in Research. Washington, D.C.: author. November. 46

OCR for page 46
Bailer, J. C. 1985. Pert ~a~ results are In conflict. New Er~1aT'1 Journal of Medicine 313(17):1080-1081. nailer, J. C. 1986. Science, statistics, and Citation. AT~1S of Internal Medicine 104~2~: 259-260. E\atE`haw, M. L., L. P. Pl~;ni~k, B. G. Petty, et al. 1988. Academic promotion at a n~i~1 stool: Experience at Johns Hopkins diversity School of Medicine. New England Jourrm1 of Medicine 318~12~:741-747. Bayles, Michael D. 1981. Professional Epics. Ant, Ca:Lif Wadsworth Publi~hi~ Any. - Beardsley, T. 1986. Do libel risks precut publication? Nature 320~6~:6. Bear, H. N., D. Babbitt, E. J. Higgins, et al. 1986. Research activities of facula In academic departments of medicine. Armals of Internal Medicine 104:90-97. Bick, K. L. 1988. Statement before the House Gaven~ment Operation Su~ittee on Alan Pesc~ and ~tergoven~mental Relations. U.S. Ccr~ress. April 11. BLUFF, B. S. ar~R.C. Fox. 1985. The Darius effect: Apes In ethical questions relating to hepatitis B virus. Armals of :Cnt~nal Medicine 102:390-394. Blame, P. I. 1978. ~nen~ry on 'profe~ciona1 freedom and nsibilit~y. ' Science, Technology ad An Values (22) :43-46. Bok, Derek. 1988. Epics, the university, and society. Harvard Magazine ( - June) : 39-50. Bosk, Charles. 1981. Forgive and R~. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Braw~ald, E. 1987. C>n analyzing scientific fraud. Nature 325: 215-216. Broac], W. J. 1981. baud arm the sWuch~re of science. Science 212: 137-141. ~ad, W. J. arm N. Wade. 1982. Betrayers of the Truth: Fraud and Intuit in the Halls of Science. New York: Simon arm Schuster. Bulger, R. E. 1988. The need for an ethical cotle for teachers of the basic bic~r~ical sciences. Journal of Medium Education 63: 131-133. 47

OCR for page 46
Penman, K. D. 1989. "Hanging freon the masthead": Reflections on auffiorship. Annals of Internal Medicine 97:602-605. Byrne, G. 1988. tuning s~sd. Science 242:1004. r~1 ifornia Caucus of College arx] Un~versi~ A. 1986. Directory of College arx] University ~ for ff,e Unity states ~ Canada 1986-1987. Marlin, J. E. 1966. lawyers' Ethics: A Survey of He New York City Rear. New York: Russell sage Faction. Carney, M. J. 1986. A difficult balance: rectorial peer review in medicine (book review). Journal of the American Medical Association 256~2~:255. Chalk, R. 1978. Scientific society involvement in whistle blowing. Science, Technology and Human Values (22~:47-51. Chalk, R. 1988. Science, Technology and Society: Emerging Relationships. Washington, D.C.: American Association for the Ach~axaement of Science. Cohen' S. N., R. A. Goldstone, S. D. Nightingale, et al. 1984. Dealing with conflicts of interest (letters). New Englar~ Journal of Medicine 311:404-405. Cordes, C. 1988. College officials wary of expansion of audits of how federal research money is Spent. Chronicle of Higher Education Any 25~. Culliton, B. J. 1987. Integrity of research papers questioned. Science 235:422-423. Culliton, B. J. 1988. A bitter battle over error. Science 240:1720-1723. Culliton, B. J. 1988. A bitter battle over error (II). Science 241:18-21. Culliton, B. J. 1988. Harvard tackles the rush to publication. Science 241:525. Culliton, B. J. 1988. Panel complete interviews in "Baltimore ~se." Science 241:286. Culliton, B. J. 1988. Scientists confront misconduct. Science 241:1748-1749. Culliton, B. J. 1988. Bill would set fraud guidelines for scientific publications. Science 242:187. 48

OCR for page 46
Curdles, B., and G. Myron. 198S. me ir~vestiga~r's catty rot to deceive. ORB: A Review of mean Subjects Pleat 7(5) 1-6. Dawson, N. J.; and A. Shako ark Z. beau. 1987. Ensuring scientific integrity (letter). Nature 327. Dje~ssi, C. 1986. Sorts dilemma. ~3sc~n Peview 39(3) :405-418. Donaldson, V. H. 1984. men dims are not as they seem. Jackal of I~boratory ark Clinical Medicine 103(4) :491-496. Dworkin, G. 1983. E~aud and science. Ems in Clinical Biology ~ 128:65-74. Scull' J. T. 1985. Two askers of scientific ~nsibility. Science 212:11-14. Frill, J. T. 1988. me nature of ~istle-blowing (letter). Science 241:11-12. ~11, J. T. 1988. Science papers rem new publi~hi~ guidelines (letter). Boston Globe (June 20). F~1, J. T. 1988. Scam thoughts on scientific fraud and m~scor~uct. ogs Fornicator 21(5):1-2. E = leer, R. L., J. W. Novell, P. J. Fried man, et al. 1987. Misrepresentation and responsibility in medical research. New England Journal of Medicine 317:1383-1389. Epstein, R. 1986. On drafting rules and procedures for academic fraud. Minerva 24(2-3):344-347. Ewing, T. 1988. Australian scientists differ on how to attack fraud. Nature 332:671. Federation of American Societies for Experimental Biology. 1988. Multiple authorship on scientific papers should be discouraged, panel advises. Public Affairs Newsletter 21~6~:5. Ferguson, D. G., N. A. Davidson, and A. Poling. 1988. Request for retraction (letters). Archives of General Psychiatry 45:685-686. Fier~rg, S., M. Martin, are M. L. Straf. 1985. Sharing research eta. Washington, D.C.: National Academy mess. Fox, R. C. 1985. Reflections and opportunities In me sociology of medicine. Journal of Huff and Social Behavior 26:6-14. Fox, R. C. In press. Medical science and medical reshow. Chapter 6 in me Sociology of Medicine. New York: Prentice-H~ll. 49

OCR for page 46
Fred, H. L. 1984. Dishonesty ~ medicine. Southern M~di~1 Journal 77(10):1221-1222. I Frerdman, D. X. 1988. The meaning of full disclosure (editorial). Archives of General Psychiatry 45:689-691. Freeman, G. H., A. M. W. Porter, and J. R. Sabine. 1987. Accuracy, statistics and fraud (letters). Nature 325:656. Freidson, E. 1970. Profession of Medicine: A Study of the Sociology of Applied knowledge. New York: Dodd, Mead & Company. Friedman, P. J. 1988. Research ethics, due process, and common sense. Journal of the American Mkdir~1 Association 260(13):1937-1938. Stung, J. 1983. Researchers, elites, and people in a rapidly changing world. Progress in Clinical Biology Research 128:95-108. airfield, E. 1987. Current comments: Some deviant behavior in science has nothing at all to-do with fraud. ISI Press Digest 49:3-4. Gjerde, C. L. and S. E. Colombo. 1982. Prcmotion-crit-.ria: Perceptions of faculty members and departmental chairmen. Journal of Medical Education 57:157-162. Golberg, L. 1982. A code of ethics for scientists reporting and reviewing information on chemicals. Fundamental and Applied Toxicology 2:289-292. Gould, S. J. 1972. Zealous advocates (book review). Science 176:623-625. Greene, P. J., J. S. Durch, W. Horwitz et al. 1985. Policies for responding to allegations of fraud in research. Minerva 23:203-215. Hall, E. C., C. M. Huguley, Jr., and P. N. Panagiotis. 1985. Report of ad hoc committee to evaluate research of Dr. John R. Darsee at Emory Un~versiy. Miverva 23~2~:277-305. Hatable, T. 1983. Fraud in science (letter). British Medics Journal 287:355. Holden, C. 1987. Fraud reimbursement. Science 237:1563. Holden, C. 1988. Whistle blowers air cases at House hen rings. Science 240:386-387. 50

OCR for page 46
Hollis, B. W. 1987. I turned in my mentor. Scientist 1~27):2-4. Home, R. A. 1983. Science fraud (book review). Physics Chem. and Physics and Mad. NMR. 15:365-367. Howard, R. B. 1983. 'Betrayers of the truth' (editorial). Postgrad. Mad. 74~6):13, 16, 19, 22. ~ Hunter, H. O. 1985. Academic self-government in the United States. Minerva 23~):1-28. ~ Hugh, E. J. 1988. Scientific Authors hip and Publication; Process, Standards, Problems, Suggestions. Background paper prepared for the Institute of Mi~icine/National Academy of Sciences. It. Ah, E. J. 1986. Irresponsible aureole hip and wasteful publication. Armals of Internal Medicine 104 (2~: 257-258 . Huth, E. J. 1986. Phases and uses of authorship. Annals of Intenw1 Medicine 104(2):266-267. Hum, E. J. 1986. Guidelines on authorship of medical papers. Annals of l:nterT,al Medicine 104: (2) 269-274 . IC=E (International Nitty of Medium Journal Factors). 1982. Uniform its for manuscripts Unknitted to bi~ir~1 journals. British ~dir~1 Journal 284:1766 - 1770. ICE (~terrEItional Nitty of Medical Journal Editors). 1985. Guidelines on authorship. British Medical Journal 291~14) :722. IDLE (Interrmtional Remittee of ~dir21.1 ;rO]rT~l Editors). 1988. Uniform requ~x~ts for manuscripts submitted to bi~ical journals. Armals of Internal Medicine 108:258-265. Jackson, C. I., and J. W. Pianos. 1983. - Honor In science. American Scientist 71 (5~: 462-464 . Ja~:e~n, J. G. 1988. Testimony before the House Remittee on Gavenment Operations. April 11. Ja~te~n, J. 1987. I am not optimistic. Scientist 1~27~:2-4. Jasanoff, S. 1988. Goal Oratory Practices: R~atir~ P~nsibility in Science. Backgr~xt paper prepared for the Institute of Medicine/Nationa1 Academy of Sciences. August. Fess, L. R. 1983. Profaning ethically: On the place of ethics In defining medicine. J~1 of the African Medical Association 249~10~:1305-1310. 51

OCR for page 46
Kennety, D. 1985. Academic authorship. Stanford University. Knight, J. A. 1984. Exploring the cc m pro wise of ethical principles In science. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 27~3) :432-442. Knox, R. 1983. me Harvard fraud case: where does the problem ~ ie? Medical News 249~14~:1797-1799, 1802-1807. Kcbn, A. 1986. False Prophets: Fraud an] Error in Science. New York: Peril Blackwell. K~shiand, D. E. , Jr. 1987. Fraud in science (editorial) . Science 235: 141. Ashland, D. E., Jr. 1988. Science, journalism, and whistle-blowing (editorial). Science 240:585. Ashland, D. E., Jr. 1988. The price of progress (editorial). Science 241:637. Lafollette, M.C. 1988. Ethical Mi~r~n~uct in Research Communication: An Annotated Biblicyraphy. Boston, Mass.: author. August. Laor, N. 1985. Prcmethetl~ the impostor. British Medical Journal 290:681-684. let, J. M. 1986. D~sc1~3ure of journal referee' reports (letter). it (I 15). Irwin, B. 1987. Fraud in science: The burden of proof (editorial). Cell. 48: 1-2 . Lind, S. E. 1986. F~for~vioe ~a~. New E=larxi Journal of Medicine 314 (5) :312-15. Lick, A. B. 1986. Flaw Action of U.S. and Foreign Clinics Studies;. U~bli~hed remarks to the P - ulatory Affairs Prof";'cion~s '&3ciet~r. Munich, I. cay 5. list, C. J. 1985. Scientific fraud: Social deviance or the failure of virtue. Science, Technology, and Human Values 10~4~:27-36. Lo, B. 1987. Behind closed doors: Promises and pitfalls of ethics committees. New England Journal of Medicine 317~1~:46-50. Lock, S. 1985. A Difficult Romance: Editorial Peer Review in Medicine. London: Nuffield Provincial Hospitals Trust. 52

OCR for page 46
Lock, S. 1988. Scientific misconduct. British Medical Journal 296 (Se pterber 24). Lock, S. 1988. Fraud in medicine. British Medics Carnal 296. M~odonald, D. I. 1987. Scientific misconduct is revealed. Journal of the American Medical Association 258(11):1440. Maddox, J. 1985. Fraud prevention: Only colleagues can judge the value and authenticity of a person's work (editorial). Nature 315(6):444. ~~ox, J. 1987. baud, libel and be Libras (editorial). Nature 325:181-182. Maddox, J. 1987. Getting to gripe with fraud (editorial). Natllre 329:377. Maddox, J. 1987. Nose misconduct? Ire delay in performing an investigation of an allegation of m~scorx3uct may itself be iT~prc per (editorial). Nature 326. Maddox, J. 1988. Can a Greek tragedy be avoided? Nature 333:795-797. Maddox, J. 1988. shy the pressure to publish? Nature 333:493. thorny, M.J. 1976. Scientist as Subject. Cartridge, Miss.: R=1 linger. M~jerus, P. W. 1982. Fraud In medical r~r~h. Jc~n~al of Clinical Investigation 70:213-217. may, W. F. 1980. ~f~:iona1 ethics: Setting, terrain, and teacher. Pp. 205-241 In D. Callahan and S. Bok, eds. Ethics In H:igher Education. New York: Plenum. M~zli~h, B. 1982. The quality of 'the quakier of science': Art evaluation. up. 48-67 in M. ChotRawski, ed. Quality In Science. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Pares. Miers, M. L. 1985. Current NIH E~tives In m~scorx~uct In science. American Psychologist 40:831-835. Mi~hRin, B. 1988. P-porkpie to scientific m~scorx~ t. JourTn1 of the Anerican Medical Assc~:iation 260 (13) : 1932-1936. ~ore, F. D. 1987. False prophets: Fraud and error In science and medicine (book review). New salary Journal of M~icir~ 316~21~:1349-1350. 53

OCR for page 46
Nelkin, D. 1983. Science as intellectual property. Washington, D.C American Association for the Achnava3ment of Science. Nelkin, D. 1983. Whistle blowing and social responsibility in science. Progress in Clinical Biology Paunch 128:351-357. - Norman. C. 1988. Stanford inquiry cages doubt on 11 papers. Science 242:659. Osmond, D. H. 1983. Mali ~ 's wonderland: E~Y~#srch funding and peer review. Journal of Neurobiology 14~2~:95-112. Petersdorf, R. G. 1982. Preventing and investigating fraud in r ~ a ~ (editorial). Journal of M ~ ira1 Education 57:880-881. Petersdorf, R. G. 1984. ~ e case against tenure In ~ iced schools. Journal of the American ~if~1 Asscx~iation 251(7) :920-924. Petersdorf, R. G. 1986. The pathogenesis of fraud in medical science. Annals of InterTua1 Medicine 104 (2): 252-254. Phelps, J. R. 1982. Dis ~ ification of ir~restigators. Remarks before the Food and Drug Law Institute Symposium on Disqualification of Investigators. March 6, 1980. RS 8249. Center for the Study of Drug Development, Rev. Rochester Me]. Ctr., February. Price. D. K. 1979. The ethical principles of scientific institutions. Science, Technology and Human Values (26):46-60. Rangachari, P. K., and H. Hillman. (letters) 1987. Fraud versus carelessness. Nature 326:736. Relman, A. S. 1983. Lessons from the Dar see affair. New England Journal of Medicine 308~23):1415-1417. Reloan, A. S. 1984. Dealing with conflicts of interest (editorial) New England Journal of Medicine 310:1182-1183. Rely an, A. S. 1984. Responsibilities of authorship: Mere does the buck stop? (editorial). New E=larK] Journal of Medicine 310~16~:1048-1049. Rennie, D. 1986. Mantis the guardians: a conference on editorial peer review (editorial). Journal of the American M - ;cal Association 256~17~:2391-2392. 54

OCR for page 46
Sc~aus, W. 1983. Fraud and negligence in science. Cor~ticut M~icir~e 27~3~:155-158. Ocher, R. I., and D. J. Gr~nblatt. 1988. A~or~hip arm ~u~or:;hip working Ant the Waning (editorial). J~rna1 of Clinical P~y~h~armacol~3y 7~5~:293. Shapiro, M. F., arxtR. P. C~rn~w. 1985. &ientificm~scorxtuct~n ir~vestigational OCR for page 46
Stossel, T. P. 1985. Reviewer status arm review- quality. New E~1and Journal of Medicine 312:658-659. Stras~rger, V. C. 1986. (letter). Journal of me American Medical Association 255 (15) :2024. Barney, J. P. 1988. Testimony before me Uhi~ States House of E=resentatives ~nit~e on Goverr~ent C - rations E~=itt on man PA and Intergav~r~ta' Pupations. April 11. Tangney, J. P. 1987. Eras will out-or will it? New Scientist (August 6). Thomson, D. C. 1988. Harvard M~i~a1 School ~rarx~n. Mary 7. Tranoy, K. E. 1983. Is there a universal research ethics? Progress in Clinical Biology Rrs ear ch 128:3-12. U.S. Congress. 1981. House Committee on Science an] Technology. Frau] in Biomedical Research. Hearings. March 31-April 1. U.S. Congress. 1988. House Committee on Energy and Commerce. Scientific Fraud and Misconduct in the National Institutes of Health Biomedical Grant Programs. Hearings. April 12. U.S. Congress. 1988. House Commiti== on Government Operations. Scientific Erauc] arm Miscorx~ct ark] the Federal Rayons. Hearings. peril 11. U.S. Congress. 1988. House Committee on Gaverrm~t Operations. Federal P-ponse to Scientific Fraud and Misconduct. Hirings. S~t~r 29. USES (U.S. Department of Health and Alan Smiths). 1986. National Institute of Hearth. Guide for Grants arm Contracts: Policies and E~ures for Dealing with Possible Miscor~uct In Science. Vol. 15, No. 11. July 18. USDHHS (U.S. Department of Health an] Human Services). 1988. Public Health Service. Responsibilities of PUS Awardee an] Applicant Institutions for Dealing With and Reporting Possible Misconduct Science. 42 CI'K Part 50. Federal Register. Vol. 53, No. 181. Septets 19. USDHHS (U.S. Department of Health and Human Services). 1988. Public Health Service. Announcement of Development of Regulations Protecting Against Scientific Fraud or Misconduct; Request for Comments. 42 CIR Part 50. Federal Register. Vol. 53, No. 181. September 19. 56

OCR for page 46
USE (U.S. ~rt~t of H-~1~ and An Services). 1988. Office of the I~r General. Miscorx~uct In Scientific ~sear~ (Draft). .. U.S. Office of the Resident. 1981. Executive Order 12291. U.S. P~;ident's Remission for the Sty of Ethical Problems In Medicine and Bic~icm1 art Behavioral I. 1982. histldblawi~ in Bit I: Policies and Ire for Permit to Purports of Miscount. Finis] by Judith P. Swazey art Seen R. S6her. E~3i~s of a workshop E - nsor~ by the admission, me AAAS Soiree on Scientific Fathom and P~nsibility arx] Medicine in the Public Inquest. Washington, D.C. Its 21-22. Ur~versi~ of Michigan. 1984. mainlining the integrity of scholarship. A joint task force report for the Senate Advisory Toni - Be on Un~versi~ Affairs. van de camp, J., and M. M. Cummings. 1987. Misconduct and fraud in the life sciences: A selected bibliography of 450 Citations. Washington, D.C.: National T.;hrary of Medicine. Vanderpool, H. Y., and G. B. Weiss. 1987. False data a ~ last hopes: Enrolling ineligible patients In clinical trials. Hastings Center Report. April. Verma, S., R. A. Rosen blatt, and W. J. Holloway, et al. 1988. (letters). New England Journal of Medicine 318(1):52-54. Walsh, J. 1979. 'Unfacul~r' a gaming factor in research. Science 204:286. Weinstein, D. 1981. Scientific fraud and scientific ethics. C;onnec ticut Medicine 45 ( 10) : 655-658 . Woolf, P. K. 1981. Fraud in science: How Act, how serious? The Hastings Center Report 11 (5) : 9-14 . Woolf, P. K. 1986. Ensue to publish art fraud in science. genres of Internal M~diciT,e 104 (2): 254-256. Woolf, P. K. 1987. 'Pressure to publish' is a lame excuse for scientific fraud. Chronicle of Higher Education (September 9). Woolf, P. K. 1988. & fence needs vigilance not vigilantes. Journal of the American Medico Association 260(13):1939-1940. 57

OCR for page 46
Woolf, P. K. 1988. Option In Scientific ~r~. In Object on Scientific Eraud and Misconduct: P-ort on Workshop Name C)ne. Win, D.C.: African Association for me At of Science. Yard~auer, A. 1987. F~;tor's report-on decisions and authorships. African Anal of Public Health 77~3~:271-273. Yolles, B. J., J. C. Connors, and S. Griffin. 1986. Obtaining an: to data freon gover~t~ponsored n~i~1 r~i 315(26):1669-1672. Zu~rman, H. 1977. Deviant behavior arm social control In science. Pp. 87-138 in E. Sagarin, ed. Deviance and Social Charge. Beverly Hills: Sage. Zurer, P. S. 1987. Misconduct in rearm. Comic & Engineering News. April 13. Zurich, P. S. 1987. Works p airs research ethics and monitoring of scientific misconduct. ~e~ni~a~ & Engineering News. October 5. (unsigr - I. 1985. Standards on author's sensibilities. Of sternal Medicine 103:797-798. Annals (unsigned). 1983. Responsibilities of coau~or~hip. Annals of sternal Medicine 99 (2) :266-267. 58